9 Spots to Find The Best Pizza in Gatlinburg, TN

Pizza is often considered the obvious choice when deciding where to eat on vacation. It is convenient, inexpensive, and often features enough diversity to offer an adventurous meal sampling the exotic twists each city adds to the international delicacy.

As an international tourist hotspot, Gatlinburg features a massive variety of pizzas that include influences from different cities around the world. Here you will find traditional Italian-style pizza, Chicago deep dish, and New York Thin Crust all within the small city and featuring their unique takes on the traditional styles.

But with so many pizza joints scattered throughout the city, it is challenging to decide which destination offers the best slice. Nevertheless, these are the nine top pizzerias to begin your hunt for the best pizza in Gatlinburg, TN, with each pie being just as delicious as the next.

1. Big Daddy’s Pizzeria

When visiting Gatlinburg, Big Daddy’s Pizzeria is an absolute must-try. With an oversaturated market, Big Daddy’s has managed to stand out from the crowd thanks to its innovative and unique cooking processes.

Thanks to its one-of-a-kind brick pizza oven, Big Daddy’s cooks handcrafted, homemade dough at a perfect 550 degrees. The result is a mouth-watering thick-crust pizza with a crispy crunch that is unlike anything you have ever had.

All of Big Daddy’s pizzas are topped with only the freshest ingredients. And while Big Daddy’s offers a choose-your-own-toppings option, their pre-set pies are delicious in their own right.

Patrons to the pizzeria can enjoy pizza classics, including a Cheese Pizza and the Boo Boo Bomber, which comes fully loaded with pepperoni. However, more adventurous pizza connoisseurs will want to sample Big Daddy’s specialty pies— The Bee Sting and the Wing It Pizza.

2. Best Italian Café

With no delivery option, the Best Italian Café can only be enjoyed at one of its locations, either on Elks Parkway or along the main strip downtown.

Luckily, with a family-friendly atmosphere and full menu that features some of the best New York-style pizzas in the city, the Best Italian has a welcoming ambiance that beckons return visitors to come and enjoy their dining hospitality.

For a New York Style Classic, visitors to the Best Italian should order the Best Deluxe Pizza, which comes fully loaded with pepperoni, beef, sausage, onions, green and red peppers, mushrooms, and black olives.

Pizza enthusiasts should try the Best Italian’s Brazilian Bechamel pizza for a more adventurous pie. Swapping the traditional marinara sauce for white sauce, the pizza is topped with chicken, red pepper, spinach, pineapple, banana peppers, feta cheese, and pesto.

3. Mellow Mushroom

If you want a pizza that transcends the Chicago-style vs. New York-style divide, the Mellow Mushroom provides the best pizza Gatlinburg offers.

Made out of cornmeal and spring water, Mellow Mushroom’s one-of-a-kind mouth-watering dough results in a thick crust pizza that isn’t a deep dish. Mix in a crispy crust brushed with garlic butter and topped with parmesan cheese, and you get one of the most uniquely satisfying pies you have ever had.

Mellow Mushroom features a robust choose-your-own-toppings option but does offer set pies that include the Classic Pizza and the Mellow Thin Crust.

Another great option that is highly accommodating for dietary restrictions is the Veg Out pizza. Both vegetarian and gluten-free, this pizza comes topped with mellow red sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a selection of vegetables.

4. Smoky Mountain Brewery

While widely recognized for its world-class craft beer and taproom, the Smoky Mountain Brewery also features a full-service restaurant with a diverse menu that includes some of the best pizza in Gatlinburg.

Offering delicious build-your-own and gluten-free pizza options, the Smoky Mountain Brewery offers a pie to meet almost any taste. Some popular pizzas on the menu include the Brewmaster and the Bakers Choice.

Featuring four delicious white cheeses, the Brewmaster is topped with roasted chicken, garlic roasted tomatoes, and spinach. Meanwhile, the Bakers Choice comes fully loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Both pies offer a mouth-watering experience enjoying some of the best pizza in the city.

Of course, the restaurant’s pizzas are best accompanied by the brewery’s house-made craft beer. The bar’s Appalachian Pale Ale and their Tuckaleechee Porter are just some of the fantastic brews readily available to accentuate their delicious, unique tastes.

5. Taste of Italy

It may not be the fanciest restaurant featured on this list, but Taste of Italy provides one of Gatlinburg’s most robust offerings of Italian cuisines, including the best gourmet pizzas in the city.

Taste of Italy features a gluten-free and a build-your-own-pizza topped with fresh Grande cheese for a mouth-watering flavor that gives their pies their distinct taste.

But of course, as a full-fledged Italian restaurant, Taste of Italy has much more than just pizza on its menu. For those in your party not interested in pizza, the restaurant offers a selection of calamari, mussels, chicken parmesan, fried ravioli, and much more Italian-American favorites.

Couple your meal with a beer available at the restaurant, or bring a bottle of wine from home. Taste of Italy will even supply your glasses.

6. Ski Mountain Pizza

Located near Chalet Village, Ski Mountain Pizza offers some of the best New York-style pizza in Gatlinburg. It is conveniently located to service patrons after a day skiing the nearby mountains.

Having mastered their crispy thin crust recipe topped with pristinely melted cheese, Ski Mountain Pizza offers mouth-watering flavors for any pizza lover.

The White Pizza is a local favorite and includes ricotta cheese, mozzarella, and pecorino romano. Also on their menu are delectable specialty pies, including the Hawaiian, the Veggie, and the Supreme.

While their pizzas are sure to drive return visitors, Ski Mountains Pizza’s convenient and friendly service makes them one of the best pizzerias in the city. Offering both delivery and takeout, every order from the restaurant’s extensive menu is paired with complimentary beer nuts to go.

Offering great food and accessible service, Ski Mountain Pizza is hard to beat.

7. Slice Pizza Bakery

Located at the base of the Gatlinburg Space Needle, Slice Pizza Bakery is the perfect destination for pizza lovers, whether they are looking for a whole pie or a simple slice.

Famous for its massive New-York style pizza slices, Slice Pizza Bakery is conveniently located in the heart of downtown Gatlinburg and is only minutes away from many popular attractions. For this reason, the pizzeria is popular throughout the afternoon and the evening, as visitors to the downtown area will often drop in for a quick snack.

Some of the most popular pizzas on the menu include specialty pies such as the Philly Cheesesteak and the Pulled Pork BBQ Pizza. And when visiting the Slice Pizza Bakery, get a side order of their delicious garlic knots as an appetizer to your pizza or as a quick snack before continuing your exploration of Gatlinburg.

8. Luigi’s Pizza

Luigi’s pizza is more than just a meal; it is an experience. Luigi’s allows guests to take the art of pizza making into their own hands, with patrons invited to come and build their pie from the crust up.

The customer determines every aspect of the pizza-making process for the perfect pie tailored to each person’s unique tastes.

And once the perfect pie has been crafted, Luigi’s welcomes guests to enjoy their meal in their cozy dining area, complete with fireplaces, TVs, and an outdoor patio for enjoying the pristine conditions of Gatlinburg’s summer weather.

9. Geno’s Pizza

Serving Gatlinburg since 1984, Geno’s Pizza has mastered its craft of cheesy, saucy, and delicious pizzas.

Using only handmade dough, each pie at Geno’s Pizza is made to order with fresh ingredients and is handled with the care that can only come after nearly 40 years of practice.

While not as intricate or extravagant as some of the other pizzas featured on this list, Geno’s Pizza is a proven pizzeria with a consistent recipe for delivering all the classic flavors people have come to love from the traditional cuisine.